Monday, May 21, 2012

Is it time for change?


In the past few months many people are publicly taking the stance that the FICO scoring system needs to be changed.  The claim is that adjustments need to be made to the existing formula to better reflect the current economic landscape.  Most of these people think the system is outdated and should be changed to lessen the value that is placed on credit card balances compared to the limit on those cards and that an occasional late payment or a collection should not have as big of an impact as it currently does.  They believe that if these changes were made that it would increase the average credit score of Americans which would then help the economy because more people would be able to qualify for things that they currently are unable to purchase. 
                All that sounds like a great idea but there are a few reasons as to why this is very flawed thinking.  The first thing that needs to be understood is FICO is a company that developed a product to make money.  Their customers are primarily lenders and banks.  Not American consumers.  We do not increase their profits.  Their main asset that makes their entire business run is the formula that they have created, tested, analyzed and developed know as the FICO score.  If you owned a very lucrative business and your main customer had no complaints with your product would you completely change your product for a few that didn’t like it?
                The next point lost by those waiving the banner for change is, what is the purpose of the FICO score in the first place?  If you don’t actually know what the product is designed to do in the first place, it makes it hard to make an educated comment that it should just be changed.  The purpose of the FICO score is predict the statistical chance of a consumer being 90 days late or more in the next 2 years on a loan/credit card obligation.  The key word is “predict”.   Having years of data and millions of samples as the foundation for their product evidently is not enough for some people.  If they change things just too arbitrarily inflate people’s scores all they would do is make their product less valuable and end up upsetting their main customer base in the process.  It will never happen and in my opinion there is no need too, the product does what it is supposed to do.  I am not a FICO score apologist, but in this case the argument made publicly by many is one that is not properly thought out and being made to the wrong people.  If you really want change, and the basis for change is that more people need to be able to qualify for loans.  Then the outcry needs to be directed at banks, and more importantly the credit reporting agencies.  The FICO score is only as good as the data that it has to analyze.  The problem isn’t the score; the problem is the people reporting to the bureaus and the bureaus themselves!  Credit bureaus make money by storing and selling data.  Nowhere in that statement did I say “accurate” data.  In dealing with credit bureaus on a daily basis I do not believe the accuracy of the data is a very high concern of theirs.  If it was they would do several things differently!
                Don’t hold your breath waiting for people to make FICO tweak their model to better reflect the current economic challenges, that isn’t going to happen.  A better use of your effort would be to direct it towards the credit bureaus who have sloppy reporting and find as many ways possible to not really help consumers that have inaccurate or unverifiable items on their credit report.

Tuesday, April 17, 2012

Big mortgage changes are happening...or maybe not!

Watching the Federal Housing Administration try to change their guidelines over the last few months reminds me of a bad movie where a random person is mistaken for a trained Police Officer. Then thrown out in the middle of a busy intersection and expected to direct traffic. The person tries their best but after several “go, stop, wait, slowdowns and ut oh’s” we are left with a 50 car pileup and a huge mess to clean up. Let’s take a look at how they have done so far and what the proposed changes have been.

In late February, they announced they were set to go ahead with new changes effective April 1st, 2012. The main issues that were to be affected by these new rules were “disputed accounts” and unpaid collections, Profit & loss accounts and charged off accounts. The highlights of this first proposed change that was if the total outstanding balances of ALL disputed accounts and ALL collection, P&L and charged off accounts regardless of age, is $1,000 or greater, the account must be:

· Verified as not a debt to the borrower; OR

  • In a repayment arrangement with a minimum 3 months of verified payments documented as paid as agreed and those payments included in the borrower’s debt-to-income ratios; OR
  • Paid in full, prior to, or at the time of closing.

After this bold stance they came back around the start of April with a slight “slowdown” and made a few concessions. Here is the summary of those changes;

  • P&L, charged off and repossession accounts will NOT be considered collection accounts or subject to the guidance of the new changes
  • Borrowers will be exempt from the new rules if the disputed collection with an aggregate amount of $1,000 or greater was a result of “life events” such as medical, death, divorce, loss of employment, etc. may be acceptable as long as the borrower provides a written explanation AND documentation.

Also in this set of updates if the credit report reveals that the borrower is disputing any credit accounts, there will be additional restrictions placed on that persons ability to qualify for an FHA loan unless;

  • The total outstanding balance of all disputed accounts are less than $1,000 AND
  • Disputed accounts are aged no less than two years from the date of last activity as indicated on the most recent credit report.

Now it is time for the “ut oh” just before the 50 car pileup took place…they announced the latest set of changes have now been postponed until July 1st!

Watching this unfold, one is left scratching their head. It is just another classic case of people making decisions about something they really don’t know anything about in the first place and having no clue at how massive the ripple effect of a terrible change like this might be.

By restricting people’s ability to “dispute” inaccurate, unverifiable or outdated accounts on their credit report , FHA is basically taking the stance that the credit bureaus rarely make a mistake and they are deeply concerned about the accuracy of what they report on a persons credit report. The problem with that stance is it’s been estimated that roughly 79% of credit reports have serious errors on them! Not exactly a number that says the system is so good that we can actually strip consumers of their rights to have an accurate report.

This bit about if a collection is more recent than two years old based on the date of last activity then it falls into these new guidelines, just might be the biggest joke of all in my mind. Let me preface, I am not making an opinion about whether the collection needs to be paid or not, I am committing on the method that will be used to determine if it needs to be paid. The date of last activity is supposed to reflect the last time a payment was made on the account or new terms were agreed to. The problem with this is most collection companies know as much about this as FHA apparently knows about credit reporting. Collection companies already falsely update this date all the time. What do you think will happen once they realize that as long as they keep updating this date, the chance of them collecting on this debt is astronomically higher? I’m going to make a prediction that a lot of collection companies will just make this normal business practice and always update that date on a monthly basis.

If these rules come into play, the big winners will be collection companies and credit bureaus. If that was FHA’s goal when they threw out these changes, then mission accomplished. Let’s hope this waiting period is one that will help FHA realize their changes will completely miss the mark of what they are trying to accomplish!

Tuesday, March 13, 2012

Why is 50 points such a big deal?

Just about everyone understands that your credit score is a very important number when it comes to your financial livelihood, but have you ever thought to understand why? The purpose of the FICO score is to predict the statistical chance of a consumer being 90 days late or more in the next two years. But more importantly let’s take a look at categorically how this breaks down in the eyes of your potential lender.

Below is a chart that indicates the odds of a consumer becoming 90 days late or more.

Score

Odds

800 & above

1%

750 to 799

2%

700 to 749

5%

650 to 699

14%

600 to 649

31%

550 to 599

51%

500 to 549

70%

Below 500

89%

Here is a real world example of how this chart works. Let’s assume that two people come to you and ask to borrow $5,000 from you. The only difference is that one person has a FICO score of 740 and the other has a score of a 549. How long would it take you to decide who you would give the money too? Understand the person with a 549 score means there is a 70% chance that person will be 90 days late or more in the next two years vs. the person with the 740 who has only a 2% chance of being late! Do you think that if you decided to lend your money to both people that you might have different rates and or fees between the two loans?

I understand the credit scoring process can be frustrating and very complicated, but the purpose of the system is very clear. It is all about predictive information for the purposes of lenders deciding who to lend money too and with what terms.

Based on this chart you can see how critical a few points can be, in some instances it means over a 50% less chance of being 90 days late or more depending on the score.

Tuesday, February 14, 2012

You Still Have Options!

If you recently applied for a credit card but were declined because you have bad credit or no credit history, don’t lose hope. You still have options!

There are two types of cards that you need to be aware of in this situation: secured credit cards and prepaid cards. Both have pros and cons.

Secured Credit Cards

As the name suggests this is a credit card that is secured by a cash deposit that you make and is tied to the card. Once the deposit is made you can use the card just like any other credit card- charging purchases and paying monthly bills. In addition, if you maintain a regular payment history, the card issuer will typically reward you by increasing your credit line without requiring you to add to your security deposit.

Pros: The monthly payments made on most secured credit cards are reported to the credit bureaus. For this reason, a secured credit card can help you build a good credit history — as long as you pay the bills on time.

Cons: The main disadvantage of secured credit cards is the cost. Because these cards cater to higher-risk consumers, most issuers of secured cards charge higher fees and interest rates.

Watch out: Avoid online credit card applications that don’t enable you to see the card terms and conditions until you’ve gone through the application process. They are likely to hide sneaky terms, like charges for increasing your credit limit or high annual fees. Also watch out for secured credit cards with high interest rates.

Prepaid cards
Prepaid cards look like credit cards, but they function more like debit cards. Your credit line depends on how much money you have loaded onto the card, and each time you make a purchase you draw down those funds. In other words, with a prepaid card, you don’t have access to a line of credit. You can spend only the money you put into the card account.

Pros: Anyone can get approved for a prepaid card.

Cons: Prepaid cards have two main drawbacks: They come with a multitude of fees, and they don’t help you build a credit history!

Prepaid cards have been criticized, not only for the fees they charge, but also because the pricing and structure of most prepaid cards make it difficult to determine how much it will cost you to use them.

Watch out: Recently there has been a lot of publicity over prepaid cards, most notably with a new program launched by Suze Orman. She is partnered with TransUnion for this card and claim that there is a possibility that some day it could be used in credit scoring. Even on the card’s website Orman says, "I'm proud to say that the Approved Card is the first prepaid card in history to share information with TransUnion, a major credit bureau." The actual truth behind all of this is if you sign up for new card and then opt into an anonymous pilot program for 18 to 24 months you can give TransUnion permission to use that data to see if they can find anything with your spending habits on this card that might be helpful for credit scoring purposes! That information isn’t as catchy as simply saying “the approved card is the first prepaid card in history to share information with TransUnion!”

Just in case you didn’t know, the industry standard for credit scores is the FICO score, so really what this means is just about every lender that you might actually want to get a loan from is evaluating you based on your FICO score. Not some score made up by TransUnion with the help of data from Suze Orman’s approved card! Take my advice on this, if your motive for getting one of these cards is to improve your FICO score, get a secured credit card, use it properly and don’t get suckered into getting a prepaid card just because Suze Orman sticks her name on it. Do what is best for you and your family, not just blindly follow others with ulterior motives.